New York State Senate Republican Leader Rob Ortt, alongside Senator Dan Stec and other members of the Senate Republican Conference, expressed opposition to the Packaging Reduction and Recycling Infrastructure Act (S.1464). The bill is viewed by these lawmakers as a significant burden on businesses that could lead to increased costs for consumers.
The proposed legislation would require businesses to register with a packaging reduction organization and adhere to new timelines for eliminating certain packaging materials. Critics argue this will increase operational costs in New York, potentially resulting in job losses and prompting businesses to relocate out of state.
“In reality this bill will have very little impact on saving the earth, but a very big, very devastating real life impact on hardworking New Yorkers and businesses,” stated Senate Republican Leader Rob Ortt. He described it as “a crushing mandate” that would elevate consumer goods prices amid economic challenges.
Ken Pokalsky from The Business Council of New York State criticized the bill’s approach compared to other states like Minnesota and Maryland. He advocated for solutions that enhance recycling programs rather than banning materials.
Senator Dan Stec labeled the legislation as an unfeasible tax burden on both businesses and consumers, emphasizing its potential negative impact on economic development within the state.
Senator Pam Helming highlighted how existing mandates have already affected various sectors from farming to refrigeration, contributing to rising grocery prices. She called for transparency regarding the financial implications of implementing climate-related policies.
A study by the Business Council of New York State projected a $1 billion annual cost increase over five years due to this legislation, translating into an estimated $720 additional cost per household during challenging economic times.
“We just got through a budget cycle where my colleagues on the other side of the aisle couldn’t use the word ‘affordability’ enough,” concluded Senator Ortt, contrasting his party’s stance with that of their Democratic counterparts.
